Module 26Preview

Structural Problems in India: Poverty, Unemployment, and Inequality

21 min read·CUET PG Sociology

1. Plain-English Intuition: The Paradox of Growth Without Security

For the past three decades, India has been celebrated across the globe as one of the fastest-growing major economies in the world. Modern skyscrapers pierce the skylines of Mumbai and Bengaluru; millions of engineers write software for multinational corporations; and Indian billionaires regularly rank among the wealthiest individuals on the planet.

  • Yet, just beneath this gleaming surface of double-digit GDP statistics lies a deeply troubling sociological reality:
  • Why do millions of agricultural laborers still migrate across states every winter on overcrowded train roofs, sleeping on dirt roads to cut sugarcane for survival wages?
  • Why do millions of university graduates with master's degrees apply for a handful of government sweeper or peon jobs?
  • Why do nearly 90% of India's working people labor in the unorganized or informal sector—deprived of written employment contracts, health insurance, paid sick leave, or pensions?

Sociology approaches poverty and unemployment not as personal moral failings or bad luck, but as structural problems. A structural problem is built into the historical architecture of economic institutions, land tenure arrangements, capital-intensive technology, and state policies.

In this module, we examine the theoretical paradigms of poverty (Amartya Sen, Oscar Lewis), the historical evolution of India's official poverty lines (from Dadabhai Naoroji to Tendulkar, Rangarajan, and NITI Aayog's MPI), the typologies and metrics of unemployment (NSSO/PLFS approaches), the informalization of labor (Jan Breman, Arjun Sengupta), and the statutory welfare safety nets (MGNREGA).


2. Conceptualizing Poverty: Absolute, Relative, and Multidimensional

THEORETICAL PARADIGMS OF POVERTY

ParadigmKey Thinker / OriginCore Theoretical Premise
ABSOLUTE POVERTYClassical Welfare EconomicsInability to afford minimum physical
(Subsistence Basket)(Seebohm Rowntree, 1901)biological necessities (food calories shelter, clothing) for survival
RELATIVE POVERTYPeter TownsendDeprivation relative to the standard
(Social Exclusion)(Poverty in the United Kingdom)of living enjoyed by the majority in a specific contemporary society
CAPABILITY DEPRIVATIONAmartya SenPoverty is NOT low income; it is the
(Human Development)(Development as Freedom, 1999)lack of substantive freedoms and capabilities to lead a valued life
CULTURE OF POVERTYOscar LewisPoverty generates a self-sustaining
(Subcultural Adaptation)(Five Families, 1959)subculture characterized by fatalism present-time orientation, resignation
VICIOUS CIRCLE OFRagnar NurkseCircular constellation of forces:
POVERTY(Problems of Capital Formation)Low Income → Low Savings → Low Investment → Low Productivity

A. Absolute vs. Relative Poverty

  1. Absolute Poverty:
    • Defined in terms of a fixed, biological subsistence threshold.
    • An individual is in absolute poverty if their income or consumption falls below the minimum required to secure physical survival (caloric intake, clean drinking water, basic shelter).
    • Because it is anchored to a biological basket, absolute poverty can theoretically be eradicated through economic growth and food distribution.
  2. Relative Poverty:
    • British sociologist Peter Townsend (Poverty in the United Kingdom, 1979) demonstrated that poverty is socially relative.
    • People are relatively poor when their resources fall so far below those commanded by the average individual or family that they are excluded from ordinary living patterns, customs, and social activities:

      "Individuals, families and groups in the population can be said to be in poverty when they lack the resources to obtain the types of diet, participate in the activities and have the living conditions and amenities which are customary... in the societies to which they belong."

    • Relative poverty cannot be eradicated so long as economic inequality exists.

B. Amartya Sen: The Capability Deprivation Approach

In Poverty and Famines (1981) and Development as Freedom (1999), Nobel laureate Amartya Sen revolutionized global poverty research:

  • Income is a Means, Not an End: Sen critiqued traditional economics for defining poverty purely in terms of low income or low calorie intake. Two individuals with the exact same income of ₹100 per day have vastly different levels of real poverty if one is healthy while the other suffers from chronic kidney disease or disability requiring expensive medication.
  • Functionings and Capabilities:
    • Functionings: The various states of "doing" and "being" that a person values (being nourished, being educated, avoiding preventable diseases, taking part in the community).
    • Capabilities: The substantive, real-world freedom or opportunity to achieve these functionings.
  • Poverty as Capability Deprivation: Poverty must be conceptualized as the deprivation of basic capabilities rather than merely as low income. Enhancing public education, healthcare, and civil liberties directly expands human capabilities.

C. Oscar Lewis: The Culture of Poverty (1959, 1966)

American anthropologist Oscar Lewis studied urban slum dwellers in Mexico City and Puerto Rico (Five Families, 1959; La Vida, 1966):

  • Lewis argued that long-term, multi-generational poverty produces a distinctive subculture—a "Culture of Poverty":
    • It is an adaptive mechanism developed by the poor to cope with feelings of hopelessness and blocked opportunity.
    • Key Psychological & Social Traits: Fatalism (believing fate or luck controls life), a present-time orientation (living for the moment with inability to plan for the long term), feelings of marginality, helplessness, high rates of father-absent households, and deep cynicism toward formal social institutions (police, banks, government).
    • The Trans-Generational Trap: Once established, this culture is transmitted across generations through childhood socialization, so that by age six or seven, slum children have absorbed the values of resignation, making them psychologically incapable of seizing real socioeconomic opportunities even when they arise.
  • Sociological Critique: Structural sociologists strongly criticized Lewis for "blaming the victim." They showed that when genuine structural opportunities (good jobs, fair wages, quality schools) are provided, the poor abandon fatalism immediately.

3. Measuring Poverty in India: From Colonial Chains to Multidimensional Indices

Rendering diagram...

A. Pre-Independence Pioneers

  1. Dadabhai Naoroji (Poverty and Un-British Rule in India, 1901):
    • The first scholar to formulate a scientific poverty line for India.
    • Based his estimate on the "Jail Cost of Living" (the minimal cost of basic diet—flour, dal, mutton, oil—provided to prisoners in British Indian jails). He adjusted this for the civilian population, arriving at a subsistence threshold of ₹16 to ₹35 per capita per year (at 1867–68 prices).
  2. National Planning Committee (1938): Set up by Subhas Chandra Bose under Jawaharlal Nehru; formulated a minimum standard of living threshold based on nutritional intake (2400–2800 kcal) and clothing.
  3. The Bombay Plan (1944): Authored by eight leading industrial capitalists (Tata, Birla, Thakurdas); recommended ₹75 per capita per year (at 1938 prices) as the minimum living standard.

B. Post-Independence Expert Committees

OFFICIAL POVERTY LINE COMMITTEES IN INDEPENDENT INDIA

Committee / YearChairman / AgencyMethodology / AnchorPoverty Threshold & Rate
Dandekar & RathV.M. Dandekar &Caloric requirementRural: ₹15/month
(1971)Nilakantha Rathderived from NSS data (2250 kcal/day/person)Urban: ₹22.50/month Headcount: c. 40%
Alagh Task ForceY.K. AlaghSeparate rural/urbanRural: 2400 kcal/day
(1979)(Planning Commission)calorie consumption based on 1973-74 NSSUrban: 2100 kcal/day Derived spending line
Lakdawala Comm.D.T. LakdawalaDisaggregated State-Retained Alagh calorie
(1993)(Planning Commission)specific poverty lines using CPI-AL & CPI-IWnorms; updated with state consumer indices
Tendulkar Comm.Suresh TendulkarDiscarded calorieRural: ₹816/mo (₹27/day)
(2009)(Report submitted 2009; applied to 2011-12 data)anchor; adopted MRP; included Health & Ed.Urban: ₹1000/mo (₹33/day) All-India Poverty: 21.9%
Rangarajan Comm.C. RangarajanAdopted MMRP; separateRural: ₹972/mo (₹32/day)
(2014)(Expert Group Report)nutrient & non-food expenditure basketsUrban: ₹1407/mo (₹47/day) All-India Poverty: 29.5%

1. The Suresh Tendulkar Committee (2009)

The Tendulkar Committee revolutionized poverty estimation in India:

  • Discarded the Calorie Anchor: Found that calorie consumption was declining across all income classes in India due to mechanization and lifestyle changes; therefore, pegging poverty to 2400/2100 calories gave distorted results.
  • Uniform Poverty Line Basket (PLB): Used the urban consumption basket as the uniform benchmark across both rural and urban India.
  • Incorporated Health and Education: Explicitly factored in the soaring private household out-of-pocket expenditure on private schooling and healthcare, which previous committees had assumed were provided free by the state.
  • Mixed Reference Period (MRP): Captured consumption of low-frequency items (clothing, footwear, durable goods, education, institutional medical care) over a 365-day recall period, and food items over a 30-day recall period.
  • Poverty Headcount Ratio (2011–12):
    • Rural Poverty Line: ₹816 per capita per month (approximately ₹27.20 per day).
    • Urban Poverty Line: ₹1,000 per capita per month (approximately ₹33.33 per day).
    • Resulting Poverty Rate: 21.9% of total population (25.7% in rural, 13.7% in urban areas; total ~269 million people).

2. The C. Rangarajan Committee (2014)

Appointed following immense public outcry over Tendulkar’s low poverty line (the infamous "₹32 a day" debate):

  • Adopted the Modified Mixed Reference Period (MMRP): 7-day recall for perishables (vegetables, milk, eggs), 30-day for other food items, and 365-day for clothing/durables.
  • Set a revised normative nutritional basket (2155 kcal rural, 2090 kcal urban, plus 48g/50g protein and fat) combined with essential non-food expenses.
  • Poverty Headcount Ratio (2011–12):
    • Rural Poverty Line: ₹972 per capita per month (₹32.40 per day).
    • Urban Poverty Line: ₹1,407 per capita per month (₹46.90 per day).
    • Resulting Poverty Rate: 29.5% of total population (30.9% rural, 26.4% urban; total ~363 million people).

C. NITI Aayog's National Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI)

In 2021, NITI Aayog launched the National Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI), adapting the global Alkire-Foster methodology developed by the Oxford Poverty and Human Development Initiative (OPHI) and UNDP:

  • Recognizes that poverty cannot be captured by cash expenditure alone.
  • Evaluates households across Three Equally Weighted Dimensions comprising 12 Non-Monetary Indicators:
    1. Health (Weight 1/3): Nutrition, Child & Adolescent Mortality, Maternal Health.
    2. Education (Weight 1/3): Years of Schooling, School Attendance.
    3. Standard of Living (Weight 1/3): Cooking Fuel, Sanitation, Drinking Water, Electricity, Housing, Assets, Bank Account.
  • Deprivation Cutoff: A person is multidimensionally poor if their composite deprivation score is 33.33% or higher.

Unlock Sociology

You've reached the end of the free preview. Get unlimited access to the complete course material and boost your preparation.

₹149/ subject
One-time payment · Complete access
Feature
Free Trial
Pro (₹149)
Full-Length Mocks75 MCQs · 90 Mins · NTA CBT Simulation
1 Mock
All 20 Mocks
Official PYQ ArchiveTimed CBT papers with +4/-1 marking
2025 Only
2023–2026 Archive
Syllabus Study ModulesComplete academic textbook notes
First 2 Units
All Units & Notes
3-Tier ExplanationsCore concepts, derivations & distractor analysis
Answer key only
Full Derivations
Analytics & TrendsSubject-scoped accuracy & question trends
Basic Score
Detailed History
License ValidityUnlimited access across all your devices
Preview Only
Full 2027 Season
Secured by Razorpay