Module 18Preview

Field View, Structural-Functionalism & Caste Dynamics: Srinivas, Dumont, and Dube

15 min read·CUET PG Sociology

1. Plain-English Intuition: Stepping Out of Ancient Libraries into Real Villages

For over a century, European scholars and orthodox Indian Brahmins studied Indian society by reading ancient palm-leaf manuscripts and Sanskrit legal codes written thousands of years ago (Manusmriti, Upanishads, Shastras). This approach claimed that India was a timeless, frozen world where the Brahmin priest sat unchallenged at the apex, the King followed his spiritual commands, and the lower castes accepted their hereditary fate without resistance.

In the late 1940s and 1950s, a dramatic intellectual revolution erupted:

  • M.N. Srinivas packed his bags, walked into the dusty village of Rampura in southern Karnataka, and lived among the villagers for months as a participant observer.
  • What did he discover? The ancient Sanskrit texts had lied. In the real, lived world of the village, the poor Brahmin priest had to bow deferentially before the wealthy, land-owning Okkaliga peasant who owned hundreds of acres of fertile soil, commanded muscle power, and settled village disputes.
  • Srinivas demonstrated that we must abandon the "Book View" (the idealized, upper-caste textual fantasy) in favor of the "Field View" (the empirical, lived, negotiable reality observed through direct anthropological fieldwork).

In this module, we examine the three titans who transformed modern Indian sociology through structural-functionalism and structuralism: M.N. Srinivas (Sanskritization, Westernization, and Dominant Caste), Louis Dumont (the structural opposition of the Pure and the Impure in Homo Hierarchicus), and S.C. Dube (the village community in Shamirpet and the multi-tiered model of Indian traditions).


2. The Great Methodological Divide: Book View vs. Field View

BOOK VIEW VS. FIELD VIEW IN INDIAN SOCIOLOGY

DimensionThe Book View (Indological)The Field View (Empirical/Anthrop.)
Primary Data SourceAncient Sanskrit texts, sacred Shastras, epics, DharmashastrasIntensive participant observation, fieldnotes, living in the village
Image of SocietyStatic, harmonious, immutable, four-fold Varna hierarchyDynamic, flexible, conflict-ridden, localized, thousands of Jatis
Primary Actor of StatusBrahmin as absolute master of the social universeDominant Landowning Caste wields real secular and physical power
Mobility MechanismRigid, zero mobility (absolute cosmic predestination)Positional mobility through Sanskritization and economic power
Key ChampionEarly Indologists, G.S. GhuryeM.N. Srinivas, S.C. Dube, Kathleen Gough, F.G. Bailey, McKim Marriott

3. M.N. Srinivas: The Master of the Field View

Mysore Narasimhachar Srinivas (1916–1999) studied under G.S. Ghurye at Bombay and subsequently completed his doctorate at Oxford under the founding fathers of British Structural-Functionalism, A.R. Radcliffe-Brown and E.E. Evans-Pritchard. He founded the prestigious Departments of Sociology at the Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda (1951) and the Delhi School of Economics (1959).

Rendering diagram...

A. The Discovery of Sanskritization

Srinivas first introduced this concept in his classic Oxford doctoral monograph, Religion and Society among the Coorgs of South India (1952). He initially labeled it "Brahmanization", because he observed the Coorgs (Kodavas) adopting the dietary rules, rituals, and clothing of Brahmins to claim higher status.

In Social Change in Modern India (1966), Srinivas broadened the term to Sanskritization:

"Sanskritization is the process by which a 'low' Hindu caste, or tribal or other group, changes its customs, ritual, ideology, and way of life in the direction of a high, and frequently, 'twice-born' (dwija) caste."

Key Structural Features of Sanskritization:

  1. Positional vs. Structural Change: Srinivas emphasized that Sanskritization leads only to positional change for a particular caste within the local hierarchy; it does not lead to structural change of the caste system itself. The hierarchy remains intact; one group simply moves up a rung while pushing others down.
  2. Economic & Political Precondition: A low caste cannot Sanskritize through rituals alone. It must first acquire secular power—either by accumulating wealth, clearing new agricultural land, or providing military service to local kings. Only after securing secular power does it adopt Sanskritic rituals (wearing the sacred thread yajnopavita, giving up liquor and beef, practicing vegetarianism, enforcing child marriage and banning widow remarriage) to legitimize its newly gained status.
  3. Multiple Models of Sanskritization: Sanskritization is not always the imitation of Brahmins. Srinivas identified three distinct caste models of emulation:
    • Brahmanical Model: Emphasizes vegetarianism, teetotalism, complex Vedic rituals, and purity rules.
    • Kshatriya (King/Warrior) Model: Emphasizes martial prowess, meat-eating, hunting, royal patronage, and chivalric honor (e.g., lower castes claiming Rajput status via "Rajputization").
    • Vaishya (Merchant) Model: Emphasizes thrift, commercial ethics, and vegetarian piety.
  4. Structural Limits of Sanskritization (Owen Lynch's Agra Study):
    • Sociologist Owen M. Lynch (The Politics of Untouchability, 1969) demonstrated that Sanskritization has severe structural ceilings for Untouchables.
    • Studying the Jatavs (Chamar community) of Agra, Lynch revealed that the Jatavs initially attempted Sanskritization—adopting sacred threads, vegetarianism, and claiming Yaduvanshi Kshatriya status through the Arya Samaj.
    • When upper castes violently suppressed their ritual claims and enforced economic boycotts, the Jatavs abandoned Sanskritization in favor of political mobilization under Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, legal struggles for affirmative action, and mass conversion to Buddhism.
    • Lynch proved that in a democratic republic, political assertion and constitutional rights supersede ritual imitation as the primary vehicle for lower-caste emancipation.

B. Westernization

In Social Change in Modern India (1966), Srinivas defined Westernization as:

"The changes brought about in Indian society and culture as a result of over 150 years of British rule, and the term subsumes changes occurring at different levels... technology, institutions, ideology, values."

  • Two Core Values: Westernization introduced Humanitarianism (compassion for all human beings, leading to the abolition of Sati, untouchability reforms, and public health) and Rationalism (scientific inquiry and secular governance).
  • The Dialectic with Sanskritization: Srinivas noted a fascinating sociological paradox in modern India: while lower castes were Sanskritizing (adopting sacred threads, orthodox rituals, and vegetarianism to move up locally), the upper castes were Westernizing (abandoning orthodox ritual taboos, wearing European clothes, eating in secular restaurants, and entering corporate careers).

C. The Theory of the Dominant Caste

In his 1959 paper "The Dominant Caste in Rampura" (published in American Anthropologist), Srinivas revolutionized the sociology of power:

  • In ancient texts, Brahmins held ultimate supremacy. In the empirical village reality, secular power was commanded by the Dominant Caste.
  • The Four Canonical Criteria of a Dominant Caste:
    1. Numerical Strength: Constituting a sizable demographic proportion of the village population.
    2. Economic Power (Arable Land): Monopolizing ownership of the major portion of fertile agricultural land in the village.
    3. Political Power & Physical Might: Command over muscle power and local political leadership.
    4. High Place in the Local Hierarchy: While not necessarily Brahmin, it must possess a respectable ritual standing (usually peasant/Kshatriya castes). (Srinivas later added a fifth criterion: access to Western education and modern urban white-collar jobs).
  • Examples of Dominant Castes:
    • Okkaligas and Lingayats in Karnataka
    • Reddys and Kammas in Andhra Pradesh and Telangana
    • Jats and Gujjars in Haryana, Punjab, and Western Uttar Pradesh
    • Patidars (Patels) in Gujarat
    • Marathas in Maharashtra
    • Vanniyars and Thevars in Tamil Nadu

D. The Remembered Village (1976)

While at the Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences at Stanford in 1970, Srinivas's original fieldnotes of Rampura were destroyed when an arson attack burnt his office. Drawing upon his extraordinary memory and surviving notebooks, Srinivas reconstructed his entire ethnographic field study, publishing The Remembered Village (1976), an international masterpiece of sociological literature.


4. Louis Dumont: Homo Hierarchicus & The Ideology of Hierarchy

Unlock Sociology

You've reached the end of the free preview. Get unlimited access to the complete course material and boost your preparation.

₹149/ subject
One-time payment · Complete access
Feature
Free Trial
Pro (₹149)
Full-Length Mocks75 MCQs · 90 Mins · NTA CBT Simulation
1 Mock
All 20 Mocks
Official PYQ ArchiveTimed CBT papers with +4/-1 marking
2025 Only
2023–2026 Archive
Syllabus Study ModulesComplete academic textbook notes
First 2 Units
All Units & Notes
3-Tier ExplanationsCore concepts, derivations & distractor analysis
Answer key only
Full Derivations
Analytics & TrendsSubject-scoped accuracy & question trends
Basic Score
Detailed History
License ValidityUnlimited access across all your devices
Preview Only
Full 2027 Season
Secured by Razorpay