Module 19Preview

Critical, Subaltern & Marxist Perspectives: Ambedkar, Phule, Lohia, Desai, and Guha

19 min read·CUET PG Sociology

1. Plain-English Intuition: The Voice from Below

For decades, mainstream Indian history and sociology were written from the perspective of the triumphant elites:

  • Colonial British historians claimed they brought law, railways, and civilization to a squabbling subcontinent.
  • Nationalist historians and Indologists claimed that high-caste Hindu leaders, saints, and nationalist politicians benevolently represented the entire Indian people.
  • But what about the millions of landless Dalit agricultural laborers, tribal forest-dwellers, and poor sharecroppers who tilled the fields, cleaned the sewers, and suffered under the whip of both British revenue collectors and local high-caste landlords?

A radical counter-tradition arose to shatter this elite consensus:

  • Jyotirao Phule and B.R. Ambedkar looked at Indian society not from the sacred temple steps, but from the perspective of the Shudras and Ati-Shudras (Dalits), exposing caste as a violent, religiously sanctioned system of human degradation and forced labor.
  • Ram Manohar Lohia injected a sharp socialist critique, declaring that in India, "caste is congealed class."
  • A.R. Desai applied rigorous historical materialism to demonstrate that Indian nationalism was not a holy, classless crusade, but a movement led by the rising Indian bourgeoisie to capture state power.
  • Ranajit Guha and the Subaltern Studies Collective revolutionized global historiography by proving that subaltern peasants possessed their own independent political consciousness, rebelling against landlords and the colonial state without waiting for elite nationalist leaders.

These thinkers provide the critical, subaltern, and Marxist bedrock that students of sociology must master.


2. Jyotirao Phule: The Pioneer of Anti-Caste Consciousness

Mahatma Jyotirao Govindrao Phule (1827–1890) inaugurated the modern radical anti-caste movement in Maharashtra:

  • Along with his wife, Savitribai Phule, he established India's first school for lower-caste girls at Bhide Wada in Pune (1848).
  • Founded the Satyashodhak Samaj (Society of Truth Seekers) on September 24, 1873, to liberate Shudras (peasant castes) and Ati-Shudras (Untouchables) from Brahmanical ideological hegemony.
Rendering diagram...

A. Gulamgiri (Slavery, 1873)

  • Phule dedicated his manifesto to the abolitionists of the American Anti-Slavery movement, directly equating the racial subjugation of Black Americans with the caste subjugation of India's Dalits.
  • He argued that the Brahminical priesthood established a monopoly over sacred knowledge, using fabricated religious texts to brainwash lower castes into believing that their degradation was divinely ordained.

B. Radical Mythological Inversion: The Bali Raja Trope

  • Phule deployed historical and mythological subversion: he claimed that the indigenous inhabitants of India lived in peace and egalitarian harmony under the beloved king Bali Raja.
  • The Aryan Brahmins, arriving from outside, used deceit, violence, and trickery (symbolized by the Vamana avatar who pushed Bali into the underworld) to enslave the indigenous populace, labeling them "Shudras" and "Ati-Shudras." Phule mobilized the slogan: "Let all troubles vanish and the kingdom of Bali arrive!"

3. Dr. B.R. Ambedkar: The Annihilation of Caste & Subaltern Jurisprudence

Dr. Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar (1891–1956)—jurist, economist, sociologist, Chairman of the Constitution Drafting Committee, and first Law Minister of Independent India—remains the titan of anti-caste philosophy and Dalit liberation.

Rendering diagram...

A. Castes in India: Their Mechanism, Genesis and Development (1916)

Presented as a seminar paper at Columbia University under the guidance of famous American pragmatic philosopher Alexander Goldenweiser:

  • Ambedkar proved that before caste emerged, the Indian population practiced clan Exogamy (marrying outside the clan).
  • The Core Genesis of Caste: Caste was created when a single class (the Brahmins) superposed Endogamy (marrying only within the group) upon Exogamy.
  • By closing its doors, the Brahmins created a closed caste. Other occupational classes were forced to close their doors in self-defense, leading to the "infection of imitation" throughout the subcontinent.
  • To maintain this artificial endogamy, Hindu society created four cruel customs: (1) Sati (burning the widow to prevent surplus women from marrying out), (2) Enforced widowhood, (3) Child marriage of girls, and (4) Banning inter-caste dining.

B. Annihilation of Caste (1936)

Written as an undelivered presidential speech for the 1936 conference of the Jat-Pat Todak Mandal (a high-caste Hindu reform organization in Lahore), who cancelled the event after Ambedkar refused to dilute his radical critique:

  1. Refutation of the Functionalist/Efficiency Defense:
    • Conservative apologists argued that caste was simply an efficient economic division of labour.
    • Ambedkar responded with his immortal sociological refutation:

      "Caste is not merely a division of labour. It is also a division of labourers... It is a hierarchy in which the divisions of labourers are graded one above the other... an unnatural division of labour based on birth, which suppresses individual natural talent and prevents social mobility."

  2. The Shastric Bedrock: Caste is not an unfortunate social aberration; it is the logical consequence of the religious philosophy of the Hindu Shastras (Manusmriti, Vedas). You cannot destroy caste without destroying the divine authority of the scriptures:

    "You must make up your mind to drop the Shastras... You must dynamite the sacred authority of the scriptures!"

C. Theories on the Origin of Shudras and Untouchability

  1. Who Were the Shudras? (1946): Ambedkar argued that the Shudras were originally an Aryan Kshatriya tribe in the Vedic period. A prolonged, bitter conflict erupted between Shudra kings (e.g., King Sudas) and Brahmin priests. When the Brahmins refused to perform the sacred thread ceremony (Upanayana) for the Shudras, they were degraded into the fourth varna.
  2. The Untouchables: Who Were They and Why They Became Untouchables? (1948):
    • Formulated the "Broken Men" (Dalit) Theory: In ancient tribal warfare, defeated and shattered tribal remnants ("Broken Men") roamed without protection. Settled agricultural villages allowed them to live outside the village perimeter to act as watchmen in exchange for food.
    • When the settled villagers converted to Brahmanical Hinduism, the Broken Men remained Buddhists.
    • As Brahmins adopted strict vegetarianism and cow-worship to defeat Buddhism, they condemned the cow-flesh-eating Broken Men as permanently impure, giving birth to Untouchability around 400 CE.

D. The Ambedkar-Gandhi Debate on Caste

  • Mahatma Gandhi: Defended the idealized Varnashrama Dharma as a peaceful, non-competitive economic division of ancestral duties where all callings (sweeper and doctor) were of equal spiritual dignity. Gandhi fought against untouchability as a sin within Hinduism, calling Untouchables Harijans ("Children of God").
  • Dr. Ambedkar: Vehemently rejected the term Harijan as patronizing. He asserted that Varna was the mother of Caste; defending Varna while opposing Untouchability was a fatal contradiction. Dalits did not need Hindu patronizing charity; they needed political power, civil rights, separate electorates, and complete legal autonomy (culminating in the Poona Pact of 1932).

E. Historic Milestones of Dalit Civil Assertion

Ambedkar's sociological philosophy was inseparable from direct subaltern mass mobilization:

  1. Mahad Satyagraha (March 20, 1927):
    • Conducted at Chavdar Tale (Chavdar Tank) in Mahad, Maharashtra.
    • Ambedkar led thousands of Dalits to publicly drink water from the municipal tank, defying upper-caste prohibitions. This was not merely a struggle for drinking water, but a revolutionary assertion of fundamental human dignity and equal civic rights. In contemporary India, March 20 is officially commemorated as Social Empowerment Day (Samajik Adhikarita Divas).
  2. Manusmriti Dahan Din (December 25, 1927):
    • At the second conference in Mahad, Ambedkar and his associate Bapu Sahasrabuddhe publicly set fire to a copy of the Manusmriti. This act symbolized the total ideological repudiation of Brahmanical scriptural authority that sanctioned caste inequality and the subjugation of women.
  3. Kalaram Temple Entry Satyagraha (1930–1935):
    • Organized in Nashik to assert Dalits' equal rights to enter Hindu shrines, proving through non-violent resistance that caste orthodoxy remained impenetrable to moral persuasion alone.
  4. The Ultimate Break: Navayana Buddhist Conversion (October 14, 1956):
    • Having declared in 1935 at Yeola ("I was born a Hindu, but I solemnly assure you I will not die as a Hindu"), Ambedkar led approximately 500,000 followers to embrace Navayana Buddhism at Deekshabhoomi in Nagpur, administering 22 vows renouncing Hindu theology and rituals.

4. Ram Manohar Lohia: Caste, Class, and the Sapta Kranti

Socialist philosopher and political activist Dr. Ram Manohar Lohia (1910–1967) formulated an indigenous socialist sociology tailored to Indian realities in his seminal monograph The Caste System (1964):

Unlock Sociology

You've reached the end of the free preview. Get unlimited access to the complete course material and boost your preparation.

₹149/ subject
One-time payment · Complete access
Feature
Free Trial
Pro (₹149)
Full-Length Mocks75 MCQs · 90 Mins · NTA CBT Simulation
1 Mock
All 20 Mocks
Official PYQ ArchiveTimed CBT papers with +4/-1 marking
2025 Only
2023–2026 Archive
Syllabus Study ModulesComplete academic textbook notes
First 2 Units
All Units & Notes
3-Tier ExplanationsCore concepts, derivations & distractor analysis
Answer key only
Full Derivations
Analytics & TrendsSubject-scoped accuracy & question trends
Basic Score
Detailed History
License ValidityUnlimited access across all your devices
Preview Only
Full 2027 Season
Secured by Razorpay